Inkwell
FIG.I / EVENT 25

Herzog: 'It Is Forbidden to Abuse Prisoners.' Ben-Gvir: A President Who Calls Citizens Brutes Isn't Fit to Serve.

PRESIDENT ISAAC HERZOG · MAY 24, 2026 · ISRAEL / DETAINEES

PRESIDENT ISAAC HERZOG
"It is forbidden to abuse prisoners"
"A president who calls hundreds of thousands of Israeli citizens brutes is not fit to be president. Full stop."— Ben-Gvir on X, May 24
What happened

On May 24, 2026, President Isaac Herzog spoke at the Jerusalem Unity Prize ceremony, condemning settler violence as 'brutishness' by an 'anarchist mob' and stating it is forbidden to abuse prisoners regardless of their crimes. The remarks were widely read as a response to Ben-Gvir's flotilla video four days earlier. Ben-Gvir demanded Herzog's ouster, saying a president who calls citizens brutes is unfit.

What the press did with it

Framed as Herzog vs Ben-Gvir feud and presidential rhetoric. Less coverage of the structural point: the head of state said prisoner abuse is forbidden while the national security minister who posted detainee humiliation remains in government. Netanyahu had already said Ben-Gvir's conduct wasn't Israel's values — nothing in the news cycle tracked what changed.

The question that didn't get asked

Two senior officials, same week, opposite moral claims — both on the record. Herzog drew a red line on prisoners. Ben-Gvir drew a line on the president's legitimacy. The press covered the fight. It did not cover who controls detention policy when both men still hold office.